Monday, 12 January 2009

Economics of Digital Preservation



The Blue Ribbon Task Force on Sustainable Digital Preservation and Access published in December 2008 the report "Sustaining the Digital Investment: Issues and Challenges of Economically Sustainable Digital Preservation". 

This Task Force made up of international leading experts in digital preservation and curation has been brought together to investigate issues around the economic sustainability of digital information. This first report presents a conceptual framework that will guide the Task Force efforts in 2009. 

A definition is provided for economically sustainable digital preservation: 

“set of business, social, technological, and policy mechanisms that encourage the gathering of important information assets into digital preservation systems, and support the indefinite persistence of digital preservation systems, enabling access to and use of the information assets into the long-term future.” 

And a set of requirements to achieve this are proposed: 

  •  Recognition of the benefits of preservation on the part of key decision-makers;
  •  Incentives for decision-makers to act in the public interest;
  •  A process for selecting digital materials for long-term retention;
  •  Mechanisms to secure an ongoing, efficient allocation of resources to digital preservation activities;
  •  Appropriate organization and governance of digital preservation activities. 

The report goes into defining business and economic models explaining how "the economic model describes how economic reality works and the business models provide templates for acting within that reality". Consequently, the Task Force suggests that good business models will rely on complete economic models and they propose a minimum set of properties for the latter: 

  • They will account for the resources used to produce sustainability and access.
  • They will pay special attention to the role of time, in both the simple sense of the elapsed time that leads to bit rot, and in the more complicated sense that over time ownership of the data and available technologies may change.
  • They will enable us to examine the effects of different organizational and technical strategies on the quality of preservation and access.
  • They will enable us to assess the technical and the economic risks of losing data.
  • They will allow us to evaluate alternative policies, including changes in intellectual property law.
  • They will allow us to evaluate the implications of the five components of our sustainability definition, both individually and collectively. 

After this, a synthesis of a review of the literature on economics of digital preservation is provided and two UK projects are examined: 

  • The LIFE Project, a British Library and UCL collaboration which generated the lifecycle preservation model shown below that helps establishing the cost to preserve digital materials. 

Figure 1. LIFE’s preservation model (taken from Blue Ribbon Task Force report) 

  • The Keeping Research Data Safe study that focused on developing guidance to enable UK HE institutions to develop cost models to manage and preserve research data. The cost framework suggested by the study consisted of three parts:
    • key cost variables and units that affect the cost of preservation
    • an activity model that identifies activities with cost implications
    • a resources template providing a framework to draw the previous elements together 

The report finishes with six lessons learned: 

  1. It is easier to ‘sell’ outcomes than processes.
  2. Avoid excessive discounting of the benefits from digital preservation
  3. Separating preservation costs from other costs is difficult
  4. Diversity of funding streams is important for sustainable digital preservation
  5. Non-monetary incentives are important.
  6. Consider the full range of options when selecting an economic model to support digital preservation. 
Overall, this interim report provides an extremely useful synthesis of the issues around the economics of digital preservation for those organizations that are considering taking up the challenge. The next report promises to offer a set of scenarios with common conditions and associated suitable economic models for supporting long-term digital preservation.

Tuesday, 9 December 2008

Research Data Management and Curation Services Framework

In the last months we have been conducting a consultation with service units in Oxford to validate the requirements gathered through the researchers interviews as well as to define what data management services are on offer and where the gaps in service provision are.


Researchers' top requirements for services were:

  • Advice on practical issues related to managing data across their life cycle. 
  • A secure and user-friendly solution that allows storage of large volume of data and sharing of these in a controlled fashion way allowing fine-grained access control mechanisms.
  • A sustainable infrastructure that allows publication and long-term preservation of research data for those disciplines not currently served by domain specific services such as the UK Data Archive, NERC Data Centres, European Bioinformatics Institute and others.
Those requirements helped to produce the following framework of research data management services :



Data Management and Sharing Plans

Support and advice to help researchers prepare their data management and sharing plans.

Legal and Ethical

This service includes support to assist researchers with t

he legal and ethical implications of creating, sharing and using data.

Best Formats and Best Practice

Support for researchers to decide which are the best formats and practice for producing and documenting specific data. This service may also include provision of support for database design.

Secure Storage

Secure storage includes infrastructure that allows storing research data providing backup and version control capabilities amongst other things.

Metadata

Tools and support to permit researchers describe their data from the moment of creation

Access and Discovery

A support service as well as tools to help researchers locate and access research data. This service could also include tools to help research groups to find about their data resources using the Data Audit Framework methodology.

Computation, Analysis & Visualization

Software and computing resources that allow analysis and visualization of research data as well as the training needed to equip researchers with the appropriate skills.

Restricted Sharing

Technical infrastructure to share research data with selected individuals or groups.

Data Cleaning

Support to clean and prepare data to the standard required for publication. This service should include help with anonymizing data.

Publication

Infrastructure that permits researchers to publish documented data and link them to research articles and other materials located in other repositories. In some cases researchers may want to exploit their data commercially. DRAMBORA could serve as a tool here to assess repositories that publish the data.

Assess Value

One of the main challenges with research data is deciding what data needs to be kept and for how long.

Preservation

This service would be responsible for looking after the data in the long-term applying the required measures so that the data is accessible through time.

Add Value

Once the data is stored with the metadata associated with it, value can be added by organizing similar data in groups, promoting it, linking it to other materials or allowing annotations.


In order to validate this framework we mapped it to the DCC Curation Lifecycle Model, see below: 

Mapping between DCC Curation Lifecycle and Research Data Management Services

DCC Lifecycle Model Sequential Actions

Research Data Management Services

Description

Conceptualise

Data Management/ Sharing Plans; Best Formats and Best Practice; Legal and Ethical

This stage is related to services to support researchers in the production of data management and data sharing plans. It is also related to the advisory services for best formats and best practice for data creation as well as legal and ethical services for data creation (for instance to clearly define the ownership of the data to be created or how can they be used) and sharing.

Create or receive

Best Format and Best Practice; Metadata

At this point researchers need support to figure out best formats and best practice as well how to best document their data with appropriate metadata.

Appraise and select/ dispose

Assess Value

This phase relates to services to assess value of the data.

Ingest

Data Cleaning, Add Value

Before data are ingested, they will need to be prepared and cleaned. During ingestion other information can be added to enhance them.

Preservation Action

Preservation

Obviously relates to preservation services.

Store

Secure Storage

This stage clearly relates to the secure storage.

Access, Use and Reuse

Publication; Legal and Ethical; Computation, Analysis and Visualization

This phase relates to several of the research data management services. Publication of data as well as access and discovery belong to this stage.  When publishing data there is a legal aspect that needs to be addressed and hence the relation here to legal services. In addition to this, the use and reuse of data is tightly coupled to analysis and computational services.

Transform

Computation, Analysis and Visualization; Preservation

Transforming the data relates to producing new derived version of them by either analysis, visualization or for preservation purposes.


And now we are using this framework to establish the levels of service provided for each of the services in the framework in order to identify those that need to be develop further. 

Thursday, 20 November 2008

A bright future for research libraries


The Research Information Network (RIN) has just published "Ensuring a bright future for research libraries", a guide aimed at vice-chancellors and senior institutional managers to ensure that library and information services evolve in tune with researchers' needs. I participated as a member of the working group and it turned out to be a rather interesting and useful exercise.


The guide provides a framework of issues that need to be considered when developing library and information services. One of the framework headings curation, preservation and disposal includes a section on research data:


"cooperate with research funders, others institutions and specialist agencies in developing a coherent and comprehensive framework of services to ensure that valuable research data are managed effectively from the point of creation, preserved and made accessible to others."
A selection of good practice examples are also offered and the LSE Data Library features there as a research support service that establishes close connections between library and researchers.

ShareThis